Are you looking for an amazing beach?  How about the feel of privacy and remoteness?  A relaxed atmosphere where everything is casual and you can really kick back?  Do you want multiple great dining options?  How about a little shopping?  The convenience of available groceries and carry-out stores?  A boat to rent and lots of little nearby islands to explore?  Really nice people who are happy to welcome you to their place?  Not too difficult to get to?